Scotch and Scholars — The Martian Homesteader With Mike Reid and Walter Block

Related Discussions

  • Jeffrey Tucker

    Anatomy of the State

    Anatomy of the State Here’s is Rothbard’s definitive statement about what is and isn’t the state. It is the core of the doctrine that drove his entire intellectual property. Kick off the discussion! Questions, comments, observations or elaborations? Either reply here or create a new discussion using the tag Library_Anatomy of the State

    Jump to Discussion Post 3 replies
  • Michael Magan

    How to Be an Independent Intellectual Discussion

    Kick off the discussion on Bob Murphy’s guide, How to Be an Independent Intellectual! Questions, comments, observations or elaborations? Either reply here or create a new discussion using the tag Guide_how-to-be-an-independent-intellectual

    Jump to Discussion Post 9 replies
  • B.K. Marcus

    Whence the State?

    I’m just reading Clarence Darrow’s 1902 book Resist Not Evil for the first time. The first chapter is a powerful opening, but Darrow seems to imagine a different origin for the state than we learn from the tradition of Oppenheimer, Nock, Chodorov, and Rothbard. For Darrow, the state begins when a local thug takes over his tribe. Whereas, if I recall correctly, for Oppenheimer, et al., the state begins when a tribe of nomads has been raiding a settled group for a while, then decides to settle in with them and become a ruling class over the conquered people. (This, by the way, is also the version of events described by the socialist utopian H.G. Wells in his Short History of the World (1922) — where, a little surprisingly, he sees the invaders as injecting some virility into the stagnant culture of the conquered people. An unexpected interpretation from a pacifist. Is Darrow just speculating, or were there competing theories at the time? And are there competing theories now? In Guns, Germs, and Steel, Jared Diamond describes states as beginning when a settled group has a centralized and unmovable source of surplus wealth, making it easier for a “kleptocratic” takeover. I can’t recall however if he distinguishes between local thugs and outside invaders becoming the kleptocratic class. Anyone able to update us on current theories of the state’s origins? @lawrencereed @srichman @berserkrl @bobhiggs @anthonygregory @riggenbach @jacobhuebert @albertlu @thomasmichie @mattgilliland (Who am I forgetting to ask?)

    Jump to Discussion Post 4 replies


Let’s say Matt Damon really did get stuck on Mars. Could he rightfully claim it in the name of the United States? Or NASA? Or just himself?
Mike Reid interviews Walter Block. You get to join in the fun. It’s Scotch and Scholars.

See More See Less